On 31 January 1944, the commanding officer of the Twenty-First Marines submitted a report on ‘tactics and technique’ that, among many other things, provided concise evaluations of the weapons used by his regiment.
Carbine, caliber .30, M1
The similarity between carbine and Japanese .25 caliber fire was confusing to inexperienced troops. The carbine, with present sights, is not considered a very accurate weapon. It tends to rust more rapidly than other weapons and requires greater care. In the case of the gunner and assistant gunner of the machine gun squads, the carbine hindered them in carrying the gun and tripod and, in some instances, resulted in the carbine being abandoned. It is believed that they should be armed with smaller weapons.
Rifle, caliber .30, M1
This weapon performed in a highly satisfactory manner and was preferred, by the using troops, to the carbine.
BAR [Browning Automatic Rifle], caliber .30, M1918A2
The automatic rifle is considered the most effective weapon in jungle warfare. It is light enough to keep up with advancing troops, can be placed in action instantly, and is considered by some officers to be superior to the LMG [light machine gun] in the attack. The BAR was used extensively in defensive situations to deliver fixed fire in areas not covered by machine gun fire. by means of the stock rest and bipod the gun is capable of delivering automatic fire along a predetermined line under any condition of visibility. Very few stoppages occurred that could not be reduced by Immediate Action.
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to The Tactical Notebook to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.